If an incapacitated party accepts benefits after gaining capacity, what doctrine applies?

Prepare for the New York Multistate Bar Exam with comprehensive study resources. Access multiple-choice questions, detailed explanations, and exam tips to boost your preparation and confidence.

Multiple Choice

If an incapacitated party accepts benefits after gaining capacity, what doctrine applies?

Explanation:
Acceptance of benefits after regaining capacity creates estoppel, because it amounts to ratification by conduct. When someone who was incapacitated later acquires capacity and accepts the benefits of a contract that was formed during incapacity, they affirm the agreement. That affirmation prevents later claims of lack of capacity and disavowal of the contract. In this way, estoppel blocks disaffirmance and binds the now-capable party to the deal. Disaffirmation would only apply if the party attempted to reject the contract; by taking the benefits, they’ve shown assent. Modification and reformation deal with changing or correcting terms of a contract, not with the enforceability of a contract entered into during incapacity and subsequently ratified by acceptance of benefits.

Acceptance of benefits after regaining capacity creates estoppel, because it amounts to ratification by conduct. When someone who was incapacitated later acquires capacity and accepts the benefits of a contract that was formed during incapacity, they affirm the agreement. That affirmation prevents later claims of lack of capacity and disavowal of the contract. In this way, estoppel blocks disaffirmance and binds the now-capable party to the deal.

Disaffirmation would only apply if the party attempted to reject the contract; by taking the benefits, they’ve shown assent. Modification and reformation deal with changing or correcting terms of a contract, not with the enforceability of a contract entered into during incapacity and subsequently ratified by acceptance of benefits.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy