If the plaintiff fails to serve the complaint within the required time, what may the defendant do?

Prepare for the New York Multistate Bar Exam with comprehensive study resources. Access multiple-choice questions, detailed explanations, and exam tips to boost your preparation and confidence.

Multiple Choice

If the plaintiff fails to serve the complaint within the required time, what may the defendant do?

Explanation:
When service of the complaint isn’t completed within the time allowed, the defendant may move to dismiss the case. Under the rules governing service, failure to serve within the allotted period typically means the action has not been properly commenced, and the court should dismiss for lack of proper service (or lack of jurisdiction) unless the plaintiff shows good cause for the delay or the court grants an extension. This dismissal is usually without prejudice, so the plaintiff could potentially refile if the statute of limitations allows. The other options don’t fit: a request for extension is something the plaintiff would seek, a default judgment isn’t appropriate when the issue is failure to serve, and a counterclaim isn’t relevant to service timing.

When service of the complaint isn’t completed within the time allowed, the defendant may move to dismiss the case. Under the rules governing service, failure to serve within the allotted period typically means the action has not been properly commenced, and the court should dismiss for lack of proper service (or lack of jurisdiction) unless the plaintiff shows good cause for the delay or the court grants an extension. This dismissal is usually without prejudice, so the plaintiff could potentially refile if the statute of limitations allows. The other options don’t fit: a request for extension is something the plaintiff would seek, a default judgment isn’t appropriate when the issue is failure to serve, and a counterclaim isn’t relevant to service timing.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy