The Supreme Court will not take a case if:

Prepare for the New York Multistate Bar Exam with comprehensive study resources. Access multiple-choice questions, detailed explanations, and exam tips to boost your preparation and confidence.

Multiple Choice

The Supreme Court will not take a case if:

Explanation:
Jurisdiction to review cases at the Supreme Court depends on a federal question. The Court generally can hear cases that involve federal law, the Constitution, or treaties. If a decision rests entirely on state-law issues with no federal question, the Court does not have jurisdiction to review it. So, when a lower court’s ruling is based purely on state law, there’s no federal question to spark the Supreme Court’s involvement, and certiorari would not be granted on that basis. If a case includes both state and federal grounds, the federal issue is present, and the Court would have jurisdiction to review. If a case rests on federal grounds alone, the Court can review it, and a foreign-law issue alone doesn't typically authorize Supreme Court review absent a federal question.

Jurisdiction to review cases at the Supreme Court depends on a federal question. The Court generally can hear cases that involve federal law, the Constitution, or treaties. If a decision rests entirely on state-law issues with no federal question, the Court does not have jurisdiction to review it.

So, when a lower court’s ruling is based purely on state law, there’s no federal question to spark the Supreme Court’s involvement, and certiorari would not be granted on that basis. If a case includes both state and federal grounds, the federal issue is present, and the Court would have jurisdiction to review. If a case rests on federal grounds alone, the Court can review it, and a foreign-law issue alone doesn't typically authorize Supreme Court review absent a federal question.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy